Skip to main content

The PsychCafe
Share, connect, and learn.
Hi,
I am very new here, but have already received so much (silent) support from the honesty and words written in this space.
I have a very close relationship with my therapist of 2 years. We are very similar in age, personalities, and number/age of kids -and both of us are gay (if it matters). There was an instant connection which has only grown over time. We have spoken about it before, and talked at length about the advantages and disadvantages of boundaries.
Recently I actually came out and said I loved her - and that I knew that she loved me...She just asked how I knew that she loved me, but then did not offer any other response. She said she was going to respond, but could not do it at that time. I am not going to see her for 3 weeks - and am going crazy hanging on this.
Was I wrong to say it? Why did she not respond?
Have others been in similar situations? I would love to know how other clients/therapists handle the love that is sometimes there as a proverbial "elephant in the room"
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hi Bostongirl,
Welcome Welcome to the forums, I am glad you decided to post. I have told my therapist I loved him on several occasions (once in writing) and we have discussed his love for me, but he has never said it. If you don't mind, I am going to provide links to a couple of posts on my blog that talk about this. I also think you find a post by Martha Crawford, on her blog "What a shrink thinks," really helpful. I'll provide the links below.

This is a tough one because of the boundaries, but I do not believe you did anything wrong by saying how you felt. I am glad that you have such a close, connected relationship with your T.

Unspoken at What a shrink thinks

The "L" word Part I

The "L" word Part II

AG
Hi BostonGirl,

It was the title of your thread that struck me first. Why 'admitting'? I thought; why not just expressing? I hope you don't feel any sense of having done anything wrong in expressing your love for your T, because I don't believe you have.

I've been seeing my T for about 18 months and I tell her almost every week that I love her. For a long time, all she would say in response was 'ah, but you don't know the real me; you only see one side of me' Then one session earlier this year she surprised the hell out of me by replying with 'yes; I know you do'!! Her acceptance that I do love her was a long time coming.
I tried a few times to get T to tell me she loved me back by saying things like 'you do love me really' in a half joking sort of way, and all I got back was an 'I love all my clients' Frowner Not quite what I wanted to hear!

Then a couple of months ago I told T I loved her as I was leaving and she immediately replied back 'I love you too'!!, and she's said it a couple more times since.

It is a tough one to deal with, as AG said; and you're right, it is the elephant in the room at times. T is forever monitoring that the benefits I gain from therapy with her outweigh any negatives that might arise from my feelings for her; and so long as the 'healthy me thoughts' as she calls them outstrip the 'unhealthy me thoughts' for her, she's happy for things to continue. One thing I have noticed though is that if I talk about any negative reactions stemming from my love for her, she will always instantly revert back into what I call her 'ultra professional' T mode for most of that session!!

I don't know if this helps at all; but I wouldn't change the relationship I have with my T for anything, despite the occasional heartache it causes Smiler

AV.
Thank you to both for your very helpful comments.
AG - I have been a silent fan of your blog for a while, your posts on "L" and also erotic transference were thoughtful, and so incredibly supportive/helpful. I have yet to find something as meaningful on the net and I am very grateful for all that you share.

Avoidant - I also really appreciate what you had to say. I am curious though what a "healthy me thought" or an "unhealthy me thought" might be...Can you elaborate a little more on that?
Does she just spontaneously tell you she loves you - or only in response to when you say it? That must feel so great to you. Have you ever wished for more? (Please feel free to avoid - if I am asking quesions that are too personal).
I do feel there is a very strong chemistry between me and my T - but as a result, it does create a terrible longing, which is sooooo hard to deal with.
Hi ((BG))

Ah yes; the healthy or unhealthy 'me' thoughts! I suppose in a nutshell, the difference between two is whether I'm thinking about my therapy or thinking about my therapist!! Am I thinking or doing something that is helpful and healing to me, or am I thinking or dwelling on something I have no control over and hence unhelpful. An example of past unhealthy me thinking would be this. T has a very active pinterest page, literally thousands of pins on there; and I would be constantly looking at her new pins. Last summer after T had a few days in L.A. she began pinning stuff about long distance relationships etc and I put 2 and 2 together and made 5, assuming T had a love interest in the US and would soon be leaving! Frowner It was nothing of the sort of course, but that unhealthy thinking caused me a lot of emotional pain.

As for your other questions; T has only ever said she loves me in response to me telling her, never spontaneously. But.......; you know when you say something to someone and there's always that fraction of a second while the other person processes their response? Well the first time T said she loved me in response to my telling her, it was an instantaneous response, like her emotional brain had replied before her rational brain had a chance to think! IDK if that makes any sense, but we did talk about it afterwards, like we always do, and she didn't deny that's whats happened Smiler

quote:
. Have you ever wished for more

I will answer you Smiler Yes; of course I have. I'd be lying to you if I said otherwise.

quote:
I do feel there is a very strong chemistry between me and my T - but as a result, it does create a terrible longing, which is sooooo hard to deal with


EXACTLY! And oh so true for me also.

AV.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×