(((((((Kmay)))))))) I went to quote the parts of your post that I really relate to and realized it's pretty much the entire thing! Like you, I'm on the roller coaster of feeling strong one moment and the next feeling like the world is going to end.
Like you, when I saw new T I would be a complete mess for 4 or 5 days, then be okay for a couple days and then the next session would stir it all up again. For me I was just too exhausted to deal with the ups and downs. Or I guess it's more like every time I hit the bad moments it seemed I was less and less able to handle it. So that's why I took a break from therapy.
I thought if I wasn't in therapy and things weren't being stirred up all the time, my feelings of pain and fear would gradually subside as I grieved the loss of old T. But that isn't what happened so far. I'm still having a few good days, then a few really bad days that feel almost too much for any person to stand. I'm still exhausted, still anxious (and getting more so every day), and still missing my T so much it physically hurts. I think this is just like any other grief, where it ebbs and flows like the tide... this is just a particularly intense and scary grief since all the attachment stuff is involved. Or at least that's my theory. Anyways, I am starting to look for a new T because I think if I'm going to have the up and downs either way, I'd rather have more support than less.
Anyways, I'm sorry to go on about myself on your thread. I just wanted you to know I relate completely to what you're going through. Your questions are pretty much the same as all of mine. Obviously only you know what is best for you, but it really did sound like your new T is really solid and that her support did feel reassuring.
If you're not ready to cut off contact with old T, do you think it might help you at all to write the letter that new T is recommending and not send it? Or you could write it and burn it or bury it or whatever. I did that and it helped to just get it out a bit. And I've also been bringing up my T's picture on her website and saying all the things I wish I could say. It is kind of fun to rage at her
And it does make me feel a bit better.
Hang in there, friend. Sending you lots of hugs.
Orbit