quote:I hope people are allowed to voice respectful thoughts of counter-opinions or disagreements here safely. It's triggering to me, due to my own stuff, to see people all go quiet on the forum. I wish people could talk openly about things.
on CTL's goodbye thread it seemed important to speak up. I feel like my expressing an unpopular viewpoint set off a witch hunt.
First I want to clearly state that my intention is not to start a flame war or escalate the tensions. I just feel the need to speak for myself. I am also trying not to be too defensive but honestly, I am feeling a need to defend myself so I'm not sure how well I will do.
I also know that it was no one's intention to cause a blowup, nor am I blaming any one person for this situation. I know that I contributed to it and I am sorry for that. TAS was just seeking support. Other people were attempting to supply support. Other people took issue with things they saw as being anything but supportive.
Secondly, I want to apologize for angry posts from me to anyone who read them before I deleted them. I was angry and hurt and did not use good judgement.
I am also sorry for deleting my posts on the original thread, I was feeling judged and condemned and attacked and it felt too vulnerable to leave them up, but I am not proud of doing so.
I also want to acknowledge that I was feeing frustrated with TAS and I think I let some of that spill over which is unfair to her as she is not responsible for my decisions to post nor does she owe me anything. She did not force me into responding to her. I actually had decided to not respond any further after saying what I did because if I was feeling that way then it was my responsibility to either stop responding or lower my expectations.
I understand that some people thought I was out of line in my comments to TAS, but I feel like both my responses and intentions have been mischaracterized. I am also wondering why it is somehow a terrible crime to offer an opinion, not in harsh terms and openly acknowledging that it may be off base, but it is acceptable for people to criticize those comments and the people who made them with no regard for their feelings or even the benefit of the doubt that their motivations were well-intended.
Irishgirl, I am not trying to single you out but several things you said on the Need to Say thread really bothered me and echoed what others have said, so I am using quotes from your post.
quote:But the main point I was trying to make was emphasis on where all of this all came from, or how it was started, since all TAS did was ask a question about why some therapists see people once a week vs twice a week, basically. Then several people started talking about the way she was posting, her communication style..and much of the thread changed to that direction. Again, I just don't know where that all came from, how it started. Emphasis in the original - AG
It started because TAS asked me in a direct question about something I said in my first reply to her. She said she wasn't sure what I meant by very little feedback. So I responded to explain. I cannot speak to other people's reasons for speaking up on the topic.
quote:The words were implying "if you change X about yourself, people will treat you differently/better". But actually said if you post like x and y, you'd get better feedback and people would be able to help you more.
If I am reading this correctly, you are admitting what was literally said but then stating the implications of the statement. I was not implying that at all, even though you may infer it. I honestly meant exactly what I said, which is that when someone opens up more about their struggles and/or thinking, people may feel more able to respond in a helpful manner. Nothing more, nothing less. There is no onus on anyone to say anything beyond what they are comfortable with. A brief search of my posts would turn up numerous occasions where I have recognized people's right to say only as much as they felt safe saying. This wasn't a directive; it was an observation. As in "if you can bring yourself to speak more, it may prove helpful." Which, very honestly, seems like common sense to me.
quote:I do know that when very little is said by someone, people might project their own stuff into that person. That's why psychoanalysts often kept a blank state years posture years ago-you can really learn a lot about people by what they project. I don't know if this is what happened here.
I appreciate that you placed a caveat at the end that it might not be the case, but if we are so concerned about not judging people or adding to them feeling damaged, do you think questioning their motivations for posting, and attributing it to their own wounding, is a supportive thing to do?
I was honestly trying to offer something helpful and share an insight from my own therapy. I have taken breaks at times because I needed to gather strength or form a support base or ensure that the rest of my lfie would run smoothly before re-entering therapy. I am just finishing a break from therapy for that very reason. I thought it was something legitimate to be pointed out for consideration. I did not at any point say or imply that there was something wrong with someone who might not be ready at any given time to engage in therapy. I also did not tell TAS that she should quit therapy, I said that she might want to consider that maybe she wasn't ready. She was free to not agree from me, as is everyone on the forum.
I am feeling hurt, condemned and ostracized but as if I am somehow beyond consideration. I very much agree with what Poppet said that everyone screws up once in a while, and if you post more, you do it more often. I just wish I understood why there is the rush to protect one member, while it is open season on others. I am too paralyzed to respond to anyone on OF right now because I am so worried at how what I say will be perceived and responded to. I am not feeling strong enough right now to expose myself any further. Posting this has been difficult. I started posting again to seek support about my mother cutting me off and now I feel as if all I accomplished was to lose something else that was important to me.
Thank you for listening.
AG