Skip to main content

The PsychCafe
Share, connect, and learn.
I feel like I ought to re-introduce myself to those who may not know me, and post a much-overdue update on my broken therapy story.

My T terminated me abruptly and unexpectedly by email back in January, after years of promises that she loved me and would never abandon me. Her reasons were bizarre, but I was very attached to her and utterly devastated. I was used to doing therapy twice per week, and suddenly I was left with no support at all. I am not going to revisit all those details again here, but if anyone is interested in that background you can read the thread “This can’t really be happening to me!”.

I tried going to a few new T’s that didn’t pan out. After a few months of that, and against the advice of the forum, I convinced my old T to resume sessions with me via Facetime video chat (because she would not agree to see me in person). Two and a half months and 9 sessions later, she terminated me by email again, this time for supposedly different reasons. When I could not change her mind by email or text, I drove to her house an hour away, showing up on her doorstep at 9:30 at night, and insisted on talking in person. She was not happy I was there, but she let me come in. We argued for over an hour, with me begging her in tears to reconsider. When it became increasingly clear that she was not going to relent this time, I collapsed on her floor in sobs. Eventually, I subdued myself as my mind was overtaken with suicidal planning, as I had no desire to go on in my grief. Then the police showed up at T’s door because my H had called them to check on me. T talked to them and had them escort me to the ER for a psych evaluation. That was the last time my T spoke to me. It has been four months since that day.

After a lot of insurance-wrangling, I was finally able to find another female T in my general area who is covered under my plan, at least until the end of this year. Who knows after that. Today was my 6th visit with her. While I am still angry that she is not old T, today I was partially grateful that she is not.

New T recently returned from vacation, resulting in a span of about 20 days since my last appointment. I told myself it should not be any big deal for her to be unavailable because I have not become emotionally close to new T (and I don’t think I will, at least not in the same way I did with old T). However, at some point I became angry about her long absence. Probably the anger was more about old T than new T, but since she sort of represents old T, she got the brunt of it. I sent her a message that said:

quote:
Hello. I am feeling an overwhelming weight of negative emotions right now, some directed at you and some at myself. Maybe they are not justified or based in reality; I am not objective when feelings are intense. Maybe I can’t be objective ever, even when calm. I am not asking you to write back for 2 reasons: first, you are on vacation, and second, I know I will not handle it well if I expect you to respond and you don’t. So although I feel like venting, I cannot allow myself to need you and risk being ignored or rejected. Therefore, I do NOT need you to respond and you can’t hurt me with your non-response. I do hope you read this, however, like you said you would. My old T did not like it when I expressed anger or mistrust directed towards her. I don’t know yet how you react. I am trying to tell myself I am being unreasonable to be angry but the tears keep coming anyway. I am mad because I don’t want to comfort myself and there is no one to mother me! I don’t deal well with vacations.

So today when I finally went back in for a session, I was surprised for new T to tell me how honored she felt that I showed her my authentic self and that she could tell my feelings were genuine, and that I had done a good job of stepping back far enough to see the emotions for what they were so we could talk about them.

Inside, I was saying to myself, “Wow. If this was old T, she would probably be giving me a lecture on not projecting my stuff onto her, and being annoyed that I did not trust her.” It was a breath of fresh air to not feel condemned for my anger.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Mad Hatter, we've not talked much but I felt quite emotional reading your post. It sounds like you have been through an incredibly traumatic time. I'm so sorry.

I'm so glad new T responded well to your email. The issue with jumping straight to the "you're projecting" part is that it invalidates those real, deeply felt emotions. So often we are taught very young that those feelings are unacceptable, that we need to put them away to make others, usually our caregivers, more comfortable.

Being the recipient of someone else's projections is kind of in the job description for a T. It is a big shame that old T couldn't tolerate your feelings and explore them with you without becoming personally affected by them.

I think new T is right too - you did step back to explain to her what was going on and you explained exactly where you were with regard to allowing yourself to need her and your worry about how she would react.

Your actions seem very brave, especially what you have been through. I hope you are able to do some good work with new T.
MH, ((((((MH)))))). It's very moving for me to read this too. I know you would have such deeply mixed feelings about all this still, but I'm so, so glad you are out of that very painful relationship, and that you are safe. Your communication with the new T was SO great, strong and clear, and I'm so pleased she responded positively. May it evolve to be a very warm and healing relationship for you.
MH, I too am so sorry you had to go through what you did with your old T. Your story though painful, was very uplifting to me. You survived and it seems to me you have happened upon a T who maybe gets you a little better than the last one. It sounds like a very good start. Life does seem to work in really weird ways. I hope you have continued success with this T. BTW, it seems like these gutless T's who terminate over e-mails are more common than I ever would have thought. That to me is very sad. Good luck with your new T.
(((MH)))) Thank you for sharing what happened with us. It truly sounds like it was a trip through hell. I am very sorry that you went through something so painful.

I do not think what happened with your old T was your fault. I think that she held out the promise, through the best of intentions, of providing you with something that she really couldn't. Eventually I think her not holding her boundaries wore her out, but unfortunately you paid the cost. It was her responsibility to hold those boundaries, and I believe the failure was hers. But I know how much she meant to you (and would have felt the same way) so it's painful to imagine how much this hurt.


I think it shows incredible courage and a strong desire for health and healing for you to seek out another therapist. I am really glad that you are experiencing acceptance and understanding and a sense of containment with your new T. I hope it is the beginning of a truly healing relationship. It's really good to have you back and posting. Hug two

love, AG
This is the first chance I've had to get back here since I started this thread. Wednesdays are SO busy for me this semester. But I have read and am touched by all of your responses, and especially the fact that anyone could be moved by my post. I can feel your compassion and it brings tears to my eyes. Some of you -- Jones, AG, Draggers -- have witnessed my T struggles nearly since the beginning, and you have always supported me even when I made what must have appeared to be foolish decisions. I am always grateful for new friends too, so thank you Mallard, Hollow, and Becca for reading my story and posting your support. I have left out a lot of details, but hopefully will have more positive things to report in the future with new T.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×